EU reserve plan needs processing investment to meet 40% benchmark

The European Union is moving to build strategic reserves of critical raw materials through RESourceEU, but stockpiling will not by itself ensure that manufacturers can obtain usable products, an op-ed on the plan argues. The action plan, dated December 2025, brings stockpiling and joint purchasing together with investment support and supply diversification.

The EU’s Critical Raw Materials Act sets a 2030 processing-capacity benchmark: capacity within the bloc equivalent to at least 40% of annual strategic raw material consumption. The op-ed says procurement should be designed with that goal in mind, so reserve purchases help build the capabilities needed to process materials, rather than simply acquiring tonnes at the lowest price or fastest delivery.

Strategic reserves are sensible and overdue, the piece argues, because Europe is exposed to export restrictions, geopolitical disruption and concentrated supply chains. But a stockpile can still leave industry vulnerable if the material cannot be converted into the specific product required, or if the processing route depends on the same concentrated networks that reserves are intended to help protect against.

Stockpiles depend on processing routes

The distinction between raw material and usable industrial input is central to the warning. Tungsten is used in cutting tools, industrial machinery and defence, but tungsten concentrate, ammonium paratungstate, tungsten powder and tungsten carbide are separate products at different stages of processing. They are not interchangeable, the op-ed notes, and manufacturers need the product suited to their industrial use.

A reserve of tungsten concentrate could therefore prove inadequate if a crisis interrupted access to the overseas facilities needed to process it. European manufacturers might hold the mineral but lack access to the form their production requires. The practical question is not only whether material has been secured, the piece argues, but whether it can be converted into the required product when industry needs it.

The same issue applies to rare earths, where mixed concentrate, separated oxides, metals and magnet alloys serve different functions and require different processing capabilities. Buying an advanced product can make a reserve immediately useful, but if it comes from the same concentrated processing networks, the EU has bought time rather than removed the dependency.

That trade-off matters when procurement is assessed primarily on price, delivery speed and tonnes acquired. Such incentives could favour refined material from established overseas producers over slower and more expensive efforts to establish processing capacity in Europe. The op-ed argues that this would risk reinforcing the supply structure that the reserve programme is meant to make more resilient.

Procurement should instead be treated as industrial policy, the piece says, because the terms of public purchasing can affect which processing capabilities are built and where. “Procurement is industrial policy, whether Brussels chooses to recognise it or not,” the op-ed says. It argues that stockpiling should not be treated merely as a shopping list, but as a way to support reliable demand and give new facilities a stronger basis for investment.

Under that approach, reserves could underpin long-term offtake and help finance European processing facilities. Contracts would still need to deliver the required material, volume and timing, but the op-ed says they should also be assessed for their contribution to long-term resilience. The proposed tests include whether a purchase diversifies processing, supports new refining capacity or recycling infrastructure, and creates a commercially credible alternative if an existing supply route fails.

Partnerships can spread capacity

The op-ed does not argue that every processing facility must be located inside the EU. It says resilience requires reliable and diversified capabilities across the supply chain, stable relationships and realistic logistics. A supply route that draws materials from several countries but sends every shipment to the same processing hub may remain vulnerable to disruption at that shared point.

The EU has strategic raw materials partnerships with Zambia, Namibia and Chile, intended to support more secure supply chains and sustainable development. The piece says these relationships could contribute to a more diversified processing network, rather than being used only to secure mineral supply for shipment to established hubs elsewhere.

That approach would need to account for partner countries’ own industrial priorities. Zambia wants more beneficiation and domestic value addition, while Namibia has restricted exports of certain unprocessed minerals to encourage local processing. The op-ed argues that supporting industries in partner countries can serve Europe’s interests by broadening the places where minerals are turned into usable products.

One model described in the piece is European investment supporting processing in Zambia, a separate refining route in another partner country, and downstream manufacturing in Europe. It presents that arrangement as more resilient than sourcing from multiple countries but routing all material through the same processing centre. The aim would be to create additional capabilities and routes across the chain, not to assume that geographic diversity at the mine alone ensures supply security.

The op-ed suggests that some procurement could be linked to European processing projects, while long-term offtake agreements, joint ventures or purchasing commitments could support facilities in partner locations. It does not set out specific projects, contract values or financing commitments. Its argument is that purchasing power can help make new capacity commercially credible if buyers give producers a dependable route to market.

Recycling requires usable output

Recycling is another potential source of critical metals, including from industrial scrap, electronic equipment, batteries and other end-of-life products. But collecting products that contain metals does not establish that those metals can be recovered to a specification suitable for manufacturing. Spent batteries, for example, are not equivalent to battery-grade lithium, nickel and cobalt.

Secondary materials also have to move through a chain of collection, legal transport, recovery and refining before they can be used by industry. Depending on their classification and composition, material streams may be subject to waste-shipment controls, notifications and restrictions. The op-ed says those rules serve legitimate environmental purposes, while arguing that policy should account for their effect on whether secondary materials can actually reach a recovery and refining route.

It says the EU should count secondary materials as strategically available only after considering collection, legal movement, recovery, refining and industrial use. The relevant test for both ore and waste is whether the material can be converted into the product that industry needs at the time it is needed. Counting collected batteries or scrap without considering those steps could overstate the amount of material available to manufacturers.

The EU’s collective purchasing power gives it a possible way to connect reserves to these capabilities, the op-ed argues. Contracts could be evaluated not only by price, volume and delivery, but also by whether they help diversify processing and establish alternatives to existing routes. That approach would bring supply security into purchasing decisions alongside the immediate requirements of acquiring and storing material.

The piece warns that stockpiles can still fail their industrial purpose if their contents cannot be processed or recycled into usable inputs. In its words, a reserve of material that industry cannot use risks becoming “a magnificent collection of strategically important rocks.” Its proposed response is to align procurement, long-term demand and investment with the processing, refining and recycling capacity needed to make those stocks available as industrial products.

The post EU reserve plan needs processing investment to meet 40% benchmark appeared first on Europe Mining News.

SOURCE
Europe Mining News


Read original article →